Sunday, January 16, 2011

HW 30- Illness & Dying- Culminating Experimental Project

The amount of dominant social practices associated with the human processes of illness and dying that go overlooked by the majority of people in this country is extremely extensive. Practices such as our dualist methods of utilizing anesthesia to "put the mind in another place" while the body is being opened up and operated on by surgeons, or how the real incentives of the American health care system are to benefit the large health insurance companies and to make sure the people get less care. However, one aspect of illness and dying that even less people look into the the ones that are stated above are the incentives of health care systems in countries that utilize a socialist health care system, such as Canada, France, and England. More specifically, what flaws could the health care systems in these countries possibly have? Michael Moore did an excellent job in his film, Sicko, of showing us all the great things about how illness and dying are handled in Canada, France, and England. Unfortunately, there is no such thing as a perfect health care system, and by observing the flaws in not only our own imperfect system, but also those of the countries that have better methods then us, one can gain insight into what aspects of health care are beneficial to all different groups of people.

My first bit of research came when watching Sicko by Michael Moore. After he finished speaking on how the American system of health care was designed to get the public less care and giving examples of how horrible it was, he moved on to what the health care systems were like in countries that practice a socialized health care system such as Canada, France, and England. Although he "tried very hard" to find flaws in these systems when he was interviewing citizens in all three of those countries, he was only able to tell us about all the good things such as how even though the doctors were living under state control, they never had to decline any patients their treatment and are inspired to help patients do things like quit smoking because of the way that the system works. The more patients that a doctor in Britain can get to stop smoking, the more money he will be paid, not to mention the fact that any patient can get any number of their prescribed pills for the standard price of just over six and a half pounds (according to the NHS it is actually currently at 7.20.). 

All these good things about the socialized health care system caused me to wonder if there even were any flaws. It doesn't seem possible to have a perfect health care system where everyone is covered and happy about their coverage, but I could be wrong. It turns out that the main principle of the British health care system, otherwise known as the National Health Service, (NHS) is that, "there should be a free, comprehensive health service for everyone according to need, regardless of their income." (http://neamh.cns.uni.edu/MedInfo/bhs.html) It is clear that the positive aspect of the NHS in England is that all the citizens qualify for care no matter what their income/living conditions are. However, the result of this extensively broad coverage is that man patients have to wait a long time to be seen for treatment as well as surgery. "In fact the waiting lists have become so long the the NHS has started paying for people to cross into the European Union for treatment." (http://neamh.cns.uni.edu/MedInfo/bhs.html) So it seems that despite the noble intentions of the National Health Service, treating everyone in a country is not quite as easy as it sounds, and it has been proven to cause long waits for patients in hospitals.

A complaint made on the National Health Service website is stated below-
My friend had been robbed and physically assaulted on Saturday. He suffered a serious injury to his eye, as well as scull bone fracture under the eye. NHS emergency doctors have identified the need for my friend to be inspected by a specialist doctor and considered for a possible operation. Now, one detail. My friend's phone was taken away by the criminals when he was robbed. NHS didn't ask if the contact details were still valid, when they were telling him he would be referred to another doctor. He and I were still on shock which was quite reasonable. So we left later. Now a doctor from the King's hospital is supposed to contact my friend but the details they gave are incorrect. We tried to call the original Lewisham hospital, but after being transferred between different lines for five times my friend had been told to call the first line again. This happened two times. At the King's hospital they cannot do anything and are advising to call the Lewisham hospital. Now, how is my friend is going to find out if he needs an operation at all, if he's being told off everywhere? Is it not going to be too late while all these people who are supposed to help are transferring the lines, and responsibility?
(http://www.nhs.uk/choiceintheNHS/Rightsandpledges/complaints/Pages/NHScomplaints.aspx)

Although this complaint seems to be directed at the specific receptionists who are repeatedly transferring the call to someone else in order to avoid the responsibility of dealing with the problem, it is still a definite case of denying a patient care, though not as blunt as the health insurance companies in America would make it. Who is to say that this kind of situation does not occur on a daily basis at all the hospital's in England? Although I cannot say for sure if it does or not, I can say that the situation above is not the only case of a patient being denied care. There was a story in the New York Times on February 21, 2008, that addressed another example. "One such case was Debbie Hirst’s. Her breast cancer had metastasized, and the health service would not provide her with Avastin, a drug that is widely used in the United States and Europe to keep such cancers at bay. So, with her oncologist’s support, she decided last year to try to pay the $120,000 cost herself," (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/21/world/europe/21britain.html) It says in the article that Ms. Hirst had raised 20,000 dollars and was planning on selling her house to raise more just so she could pay for a part of her medication, in the hopes that the health service would cover the rest. But when she was talking to her doctor, the conversation went like this, “I said, ‘Where does that leave me?’ He said, ‘If you pay for Avastin, you’ll have to pay for everything’ ” — in other words, for all her cancer treatment, far more than she could afford." These kind of stories make you wonder if the Pharmacist from Sicko was telling the truth when Michael Moore (questioning the price for amount and type of drugs being purchased) asked, "What if it's like an HIV drug, or a cancer drug?" and the pharmacist responded, "Six pounds 65." I'm sure that Debbie Hirst would not agree with this 'standard price'.

Although these examples do sound very similar to the kind of rejection that so many Americans here all the time, it would be inaccurate to say that the National Health Service in Britain is similar to America in any way as far as what the incentives of the health cares system are. I have a friend who is currently living in England and has lived there for over 10 years, and is in her late 40's. (that has asked to remain anonymous for this project) When I asked her about how she felt about the National Health Service in England, being someone who had previously experienced the American health care system, she said that it was wonderful in comparison. "When I was working as a full-time bartender making a pretty low salary[compared to what I make now], I recieved all the same coverage as the coverage I recieve now, even though I am paid almost twice the amount while acting that I was previously being paid as a bartender." She went on to describe how she had only been sick enough to need antibiotics about five or six times throughout her years in England, but that when her general practitioner had prescribed her medication, she never even had to pay a single pound.

After conducting this research, my conclusion is that I was correct in saying that there is no way to have a perfect health system, and that saying there will be coverage for every citizen in an entire nation is a lot easier than actually making it happen. Overall though, the National Health Service in Britain is a much more effective and honorable system than whatever system we practice in America, and the idea of socialized health care is benefiting a much larger portion of England then the percentage of people in America that benefit from health care, which might have something to do with the fact that about 50 million people in America are not covered by heatlh insurance at all.


Saturday, January 8, 2011

HW 29- Reading and noting basic materials

Being sick is something all of us have to go through at some point in our lives. In many cases, the most amount of time that we will spend in a hospital is in the last few weeks or months of their lives, but that does not mean it is the only time. Earlier today, I myself made a trip to the hospital for a small surgery on my heel. However, while I was waiting for my doctor to show up, all of the other patients around me were senior citizens. Although I waited for about two and a half hours to actually see a doctor, once I was being treated, the procedure went perfectly. In other words, it felt like all the patients were being made to wait for a very long time in order to receive care, but because I am lucky enough to qualify for health insurance, the quality of the care was actually very good. Another thing that I noticed about my experience in the hospital is that for a large portion of the time that I was waiting, my mother and I were either reviewing or filling out new paperwork. So although it is true that all humans will experience illness and dying at usually multiple times in their lives, that does not mean that all of their experiences going through that process will be the same.

The process of dying is yet another inevitable circumstance that all of us will experience eventually. There are so many different causes of death and situations regarding family and environment that everyone's experience with dying will certainly be different. However, in Death and Hospital Culture, it is stated that, "Today, more Americans die in hospitals then anywhere else, and the most frequent response to critical illness there is to try to stave off with the most sophisticated technological means available." (Death and Hospital Culture, 25) As a result of this, in America, the idea of dying can often be associated with a hospital bed surrounded by many machines. This is not necessarily the case though; when our guest speaker Beth came in to speak about the passing of her husband, she talked about how for the last days of his life she took him back to their house and took care of him there by herself. The difference between dying in a hospital and dying at home can have a great impact on that person's experience. "Thus, while patient and family decision-making is considered paramount, decisions, when they are made at all, are constrained by hospital rules reimbursement mechanisms, and standards of care." (Death and Hospital Culture, 28) It seems that by choosing to die in a hospital, neither the patient or the family of the patient will have much power over the treatment of the one who is dying, while if that same patient was being taken care of in his/her home, they would have complete freedom at the cost of less machinery and trained staff.

There is not always a choice for patients whether or not they want to receive care in the hospital. Unlike countries like Canada, Britain, and France which have socialized medicine systems, good health care in America is not so easy to come by. In Sicko, a film created by Michael Moore, he describes how about 50 million Americans are without health insurance. He also speaks about a man who severed both his middle and his ring finger in an accident and was offered a choice of paying 60,000 dollars to re-attach his middle finger or 12,000 dollars to re-attach his ring finger. On the other hand, Beth did not have to pay a single penny for the care that Erik received throughout the time that he was dying, because their family did have health insurance. Many citizens who are covered by health insurance in America are not as lucky as Beth was, however. Things such as pre-existing conditions that patients may have forgot to mention when filling out paperwork can give health insurance companies a reason not to cover the costs of care. The reason for this is because the incentives of our health care system are for the benefit of the large companies, not the people. At a later point in the flim Sicko, Michael Moore showed us a recording of President Nixon having a conversation with chief advisor, who was describing his proposal for the new health care system to the president. What he said was basically that, "The whole idea of the new health care system is less care." Nixon responded by saying, "Well that doesn't sound too bad." It is clear that the American system of health care is making it harder for people to acquire health insurance, and equally as difficult to make sure that you receive care even when you are insured.

Monday, January 3, 2011

HW 28- Comments 2

Ben H said...
The part about this post that I enjoyed the most was the way you were able to connect the insights you made from visiting Gloria to the insights you had previously came up with while reading Mountains Beyond Mountains and while listening to Beth. For instance, when you said, "Both of them wanted to give their family member the most dignified dying experience possible. Both also had a lot of pictures in the room to give visitors of sense of the person and also to make the dying person have good memories," you did a great job of connecting to specific things that Beth said when thinking of your own experience in the hospital. I also really liked the way your writing had a very personal touch to it.   Ben H said...
My favorite aspect about this post was how you were able to draw so many insights from a time that you visited the hospital where the patient's life was not exactly at risk. You were able to look at an experience that many people did not choose that is, in a way, more challenging, and still observe many things. For instance, you said, "She didn't want to be "babied" or given special treatment from anyone, she basically wanted us to treat her as if nothing had happened." Even though she was going to be fine, you were still able to observe changes in behavior.
 
TIM said...
I think you did a very good job on this post. I especially liked the part where you wrote how Jim was feeling about the way he was being treated by the nurses. Like when you said, "and although in this particular situation their job required them to make sure the patients stay was as comfortable as possible, it was clear that they were making an extra effort and actually felt for Jim. However, apparently there were others who were not nearly as considerate as they could have been." This really showed how even though the patient was not able to move or speak at all, he was still able to communicate the way he felt about what was going on, and it is very good that you were able to observe that.
 
Jim Harker said...
"More than anything, he was curious as to what was going on in our lives.... Jim would be smiling at times as well, because I'm sure he was happy to see us. However, we knew perfectly well that the only reason he was choosing to be kept alive was because he wanted to see his daughter grow." Very interesting observation. Jim seems to have kept trying to hold onto the good, 'normal' things as an anchor in the face of such a terrible, debilitating disease. Even when he was so incapacitated, he knew his daughter could give him joy, and (I think) that he could be a positive presence/memory for his daughter.

Saturday, January 1, 2011

HW 27- Visiting an unwell person

When a good friend of my mother named Jim, who I had known for almost my whole life, was sick with ALS, we went to visit him in the home that he was being kept in after he was released from the hospital. At this point, they knew that there was no way to cure him, so the were really just using machines to sustain him and make the last few weeks or months slightly more comfortable. I remember when Andy was talking to us at one point, i believe he said that he had a friend who was a doctor and had told him that the last 6 weeks of a persons life is always when they recieve the most medical treatment. This probably contributed to the way my family and I acted around Jim. I visited him a few times, but for all of the times I was fully aware of the situation and that he would probably not be alive for much longer.

Despite the seriousness of the disease that Jim had, he was still able to keep relitively high spirits. More than anything, he was curious as to what was going on in our lives. In the beginning, visiting him was a little bit awkward because I was not really sure how I should act. It was also extremely hard to understand what Jim was saying because he couldn't actually speak at all, he was only capable of mouthing the words. My parents would act extremely pleased to see him and were constantly smiling. Not to say that they weren't, but there is no way that they could have been as happy as they looked knowing that their old friend was going to die soon. Jim would be smiling at times as well, because I'm sure he was happy to see us. However, we knew perfectly well that the only reason he was choosing to be kept alive was because he wanted to see his daughter grow.

There were many nurses who were helping to keep Jim as comfortable as possible, and he had things to say about almost all of them. Some of the nurses were very kind to him, and although in this particular situation their job required them to make sure the patients stay was as comfortable as possible, it was clear that they were making an extra effort and actually felt for Jim. However, apparently there were others who were not nearly as considerate as they could have been. The whole situation seemed extremely similar to what the guest speaker that visited our class, Beth, was dealing with. Everyone around the hospital knew that Erik was not going to have much more time to live, but for the most part, people sill made an attempt to keep a positive attitude which resulted in the patient feeling better about everything that was going on. Also, even though it is hard to be as caring as Paul Farmer in Mountains Beyond Mountains, all of the staff that I saw every time I visited were very welcoming and kind. At least from my point of view.

Friday, December 31, 2010

HW 26- Looking back & forward in our unit

-Over 50 million citizens in America today are living without health insurance.
-Of the people that do pay health insurance companies to pay for their medical needs, a large number will be rejected payment due to something like pre-existing conditions or the excuse that the treatment is merely "experimental."
-In countries like Canada, England, and France, all the citizens are provided with universal, free health care.
-The incentives of the health care system that is utilized my America today are to make sure less care is distributed to the people who need it in order to maximize the profit for the health insurance companies.

The source that has been the most helpful for me so far this unit has been the movie Sicko, despite its extreme bias. Although Michael Moore clearly has his own opinions and represents them much more than the opposing side in his movies, the amount of evidence for his side that he was able to present was too much to ignore. I enjoyed reading the book Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder, but it didn't necessarily educate me that much in the area of the dominant social practices that the United States embraces when it comes to illness and dying. However, the book did represent a situation of an extrodinary social practice, which was the way that Paul Farmer would treat all of his patients as well as his strong motivation to make a difference.

I think that one important question that we should explore is: what are the negative aspects to the health care systems in places like Canada, England, and France? In Sicko, Michael Moore does a very good job of emphasizing what is better about the socialist health care system in those countries than the system we are operating on today, but no system is perfect, so I think it would be a good idea to explore its flaws as well. Another question that might be worth looking into could be: When did the incentives of our health care system truly become to benefit the insurance companies at the expense of the people? I know that in Sicko, it was stated that when Nixon announced his new policy is when our health care system became corrupt, but what if it was actually before then?

Monday, December 20, 2010

HW 25- Response to Sicko

Summary:
The incentives of the current health care system in America are not meant to benefit the people, but they are only to help the health insurance companies make more profit by reducing the amount of care that the people recieve. There are millions of Americans in this country who do not have any kind of health care, and for many of the Americans that do have health care, it is hardly ideal. Insurance companies will charge huge sums of money for operations and treatment, and they will sometimes even deny patients the care that could be necessary to save their lives because for reasons like that the treatment is simply "experimental" or the fact that the treatment is so expensive. In many countries around the world, such as Canada, England, and France, health care is free of charge, including almost all the treatment and medication that the patients need.

Evidence 1: A recording of President Nixon's conversation with his chief advisor was revealed during the film. One of the things his chief advisor said was, "All the incentives are towards less medical care." Nixon responded by saying something along the lines of, "Well that sounds pretty good." This piece of evidence is essential to Michael Moore's point saying how the health care system is really just set up so that the people get less care and the health insurance companies made more money. It supports the idea that this is a corrupt system, that benefits the rich and harms the poor and middle class.

Evidence 2: Canada and Britain have something called socialized health insurance. In America we have a socialized education system, but only independent health insurance companies. All the doctors in a socialized medicine system work for the government, and the one that was interviewed in the film was living in a million dollar home and making over 100,000 dollars a year. The both the English and Canadian health care pays all the expences for care and treatment of its patients. This evidence supports the point that the health care systems outside of the United States have proven to be extremely effective, and are doing a much better job of making sure the people actually get care. At the same time, it also proves that working for the government is not such a bad thing, considering the amount of money that the doctors in Britain are getting paid and the satisfying moral aspect of the job that actually allows the doctors to treat all the patients that come to see them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aZnlElJZpA
In this video, Nixon states that the doctors would be working for the patients rather then the government under his plan. However, how can the doctors work for the patients if they aren't even being allowed to treat them because of the restrictions that the health insurance companies are forcing on them? Also, what is so bad about doctors working for the government? People seem to be so afraid of having the government in their life, but by choosing to run health care this way, the government is choosing to not allow millions of people to get the care that they need.

This movie truly did open my eyes. Although I had my doubts at first, especially because Michael Moore seemed to be contradicting himself at times as well as the way he seemed to dumb himself down so that the American audience could relate, the amount and quality of the evidence and studies that were conducted was extremely extensive. I had always known that there were many terrible policies in this country, and that many of them were doing harm to the citizens (especially those who are less fortunate) instead of helping them. However, I honestly never thought that the system would have been specifically created with the intentions of making sure less and less people got the care that they needed just for the sake of the profit of the health insurance companies. My previous viewpoint on the situation was that I took the terrible health care system for granted, which is pretty easy to do when you (like myself) are one of the lucky ones who has health care that pays for most of your medical needs. However, after really taking a look, it is clear that the policies in this country truly are corrupt, and that the word is not merely an exaggeration. The most important excerpts of the movie in my opinion were the ones that showed us how bad our own health care companies are treating the people that pay them to take care of them, compared to the health care that ALL the citizens in Canada, France, and Britain are recieving. The most crucial idea I have specifically for my future after watching this movie is that I am now seriously considering moving out of this country, because it feels like the expense of living practically anywhere else in the world other than America is much less.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

HW 24- Illness and Dying Book Part 3

The book that I have read for the Illness and Dying unit is titled Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder. It was published in 2004 by Random House Inc.

Precis: Paul Farmer grew up in a less than ideal family situation, relocating multiple times in addition to other struggles. However, he was very gifted and intelligent, and ended up attending Harvard Medical School where he studied to be a doctor/anthropologist. Unlike typical doctors, (and people in general, actually) Farmer embarked on his image to do good by commuting from Boston to Haiti in order to treat infectious diseases, such as tuberculosis, during his time in medical school at Harvard. At his hospital in Cange, Haiti, Farmer offered free health care to any Haitian who needed it... he even formed his own organization called Partners in Health, which helped out with Farmer's mission by attempting to raise money for those who could not afford treatment or medication. One of the important players in the organization named Jim Kim offered to take the organization to Peru with a friend of Farmer's named Jack, who was a priest. Although, unfortunately Father Jack loses his life to a strand of Multi- Drug Resistant TB, the programs in both Haiti and Peru did an amazing job of providing care for those who would normally not be able to recieve it. This resulted in Farmer expanding the Partners in Health organization to Russia. The work that Paul Farmer has done in the field of medicine is the opposite of what we see in the current system today, and the way he treats his patients as people is a passion that would be amazing if all doctors could share it.

Gems:
"He was like a compass, with one leg swinging around the globe, and the other planted in Haiti,” (Kidder, 260). It is amazing how someone with so much success in a much more fortunate country would abandon their selfishness in order to help the people who really needed him. The man really is portrayed as a saint in the story.

"But Farmer seemed worried about the expense, and perhaps the precedent, of a medevac flight. He'd written back, 'Serena, honey. please consider the possibilities." (Kidder, 270) This quote seems to suggest that Farmer is actually implying that the cost to help these people is too great, and that their lives are not worth it! That doesn't seem like and idea Paul Farmer would have at all.

"Because, A, he's a human being, and B, because I didn't know he couldn't be treated, and C, why shouldn't he have a comfortable way to die, why shouldn't his mother have a private room without flies on her face to grieve in? Can we not have him in a place where people are trained in palliation? Isn't palliative care important?" (Kidder, 277) This quote pretty much describes the core beliefs of Paul Farmer on illness and dying. I couldn't agree with it more.

Thoughts:
When I first started reading this book, I read a quote from one of Doctor Farmer's patients saying that Farmer was a "fuckin' saint." When I first looked at it in the beginning of the book, I had my doubts. After all, treating a few patients like they are actually people shouldn't make you a saint, it should just make you a caring person. However, by the end of the book I have realized that the things Paul Farmer did for people are practically inhuman in how selfless they are. He treated all the patients he came across, and not only that, he treated them as if they were his closest friends. This kind of behavior was especialy suprising to hear about because he did not have the greatest childhood; its not like he started out with an advantage, he had to work his way to the top and from there, he gave it all back. His policies on medicine seems to be the opposite of what the United States has embraced today, and it is something that everyone can learn from.