Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder. Published 2004, Random House Inc.
Precis- Paul Farmer is continuing to make his trips between Cange and Boston, but the grip of the military on Cange was getting tighter, which did not sit well with Farmer. He began sneaking thousands of dollars into Cange for anti-violence campaigns, as well as disrespecting soldiers. Farmer was eventually banished from Haiti for his actions, and established a permanent headquaters in Cambridge. He now began to look into a new disease, Multi-drug resistant tuberculosis, otherwise known as MDR. In fact, it was when he lost an old friend to the disease in Peru that sparked his passion to cure the disease. His friend was a man named Father Jack, a priest who had allowed Paul to stay with him in his church while he was still attending medical school in a dangergous neighborhood. Not too long after Jack moved to Peru, the priest became ill and was immediately flown back to America to be treated by Farmer. He passed away a month later, and Paul discovered that he was infected with a strand of MDR that was immune to all of the available tuberculosis treatments in existance.
Gems-
"Farmer was a TB expert. When he was still just a residant at the Brigham, he'd written a treatment manual for the house staff. He had been diagnosing and treating the disease ever since he'd first set foot in Haiti, where nearly everyone was infected and active cases were rampant." (Kidder, 138) Farmer is one of the best in the world at treating this disease. So I can only imagine how much of a wake up call it must have been to realize that a close friend had died from a strain of the disease that he was supposed to be an expert at treating that could not possibly have been cured by any of his known methods.
"Others [who hadn't been able to afford their drugs] had given up and gone back to their shacks on the barren, dusty hillsides and were waiting there to die." (Kidder, 140) When I read this it really made me think about the different ways that people deal with illness and dying. How some people can just accept there fate and will embrace death when it approaches, and others will reject the idea ferociously.
"Meanwhile, here in Peru, where the government made debt payments of more than a billion dollars every year to American banks and international lending institutions, experts in international TB control had deemed MDR too expensive." (Kidder, 141) This sounds a lot like the men and women in "Sicko" who were denied treatment because the health insurance companies would come up with excuses not to allow them treatment, when really the only thing going on is that the health insurance companies are trying to make more money.
Thoughts- This section of the book did an excellent job of reinforcing some of the ideas that the movie "Sicko" had presented to me. Although I never really blamed doctors for the terrible American system of dealing with illness and dying, I always sort of thought of them as machines, who would just treat patients with the resources they had without actually making an effort to change things. In "Sicko," we heard from a doctor who moved to London because he liked the way that they had their health care system set up, and by treating patients in Great Britain, not only was he able to help more people but he was also making a lot more money for himself. Paul Farmer has taken the concept of actually helping people through medicine to a whole new level, and the selflessness in his work is something that defys the human trait of greed, which is something I thought no human, let alone American, would be able to push aside.
Sunday, December 19, 2010
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
HW 21b- Comments
- NatalieK said...
- I liked that you made a lot of connections in your post, but maybe you could've elaborated a little more. For instance, did it seem to help your mother's friend feel more positive when you avoided the subject of death? Or maybe, why was it so spectacular to you that Beth had her 13 year old son help her? I can imagine why, but it would be interesting to hear about it too. Otherwise I thought your post was really interesting considering the fact that you seemed to be able to understand Beth's motives through your own personal experience.
- December 9, 2010 7:02 PM
- Devin said...
- I liked your first connection about visiting your good friend's mother with ALS in the hospital and how you would chat about the Patriots (cannot believe you're a Patriot fan) in order to keep the conversation upbeat. I know that ALS is a terrible disease and it would be interesting to hear how seeing someone with it firsthand affected you. I myself have never been with anyone with a serious disease. I think that having that experience must be powerful and important in the way that it makes death and dying more real, making us aware, as Beth said, of our own mortality. I also liked the connection you made to Beth's taking care of her husband with only the help of her son when you told us that your aunt took care of your sick grandmother all by herself. I think it must be true that many more women take care of sick and dying relatives than men do. It's obviously much nicer for a sick person not to have to be in the hospital but it must have been a huge burden in this case for your aunt.
- December 10, 2010 10:07 PM
- Jim Harker said...
- "For as long as I can remember ... She was ill for her entire life..." This is a really powerful image - that all we may really know or remember about a grandparent is the time when they were sick, frail,or incapacitated by disease at the end of their lives. You knew your grandmother for the eight years of her final illness, but didn't have the chance to know her life prior to the illness. I think it's the relationship and history of people BEFORE the illness that gives both the patient and the caregiver the strength to stay positive and loving as you fight against the disease. That's what makes it possible to chat about the Patriots - some things you may not be able to share anymore, but you look for all the things you still CAN share. A sick person's 'road' is a much slower journey than young, healthy, busy people 'walk'. You have to slow way down to the sick person's pace, and look for ways to 'walk' together.
- December 11, 2010 6:57 AM
- TIM said...
- I really liked when you said "I imagine that the fact that Evan and Josh were so close to their father was a very good thing, but it also probably made it harder for them when he passed away." I know from experience that when you are not as close to a family member, it is not as hard to deal with their death when the time comes. So it would make sense if the closer you are to someone the harder it is to deal with their passing. I also liked the way you were able to connect the ideas that Beth had to your own life and it would have been nice to hear more about her experience if she said anything else.
- December 11, 2010 11:03 AM
- My comments on other group members-
- Ben H said...
- I love the depth of thought that you put into this homework. For instance, when you said "Without relationships, maybe you would treat death as an old friend, ready to finally take you away. We seem to only fear death because of fear of what we’ll miss." That statement really got me thinking, and was more insightful than anything I could have thought of. I also really liked the way that you represented many of your ideas. You asked the reader a lot of questions, a technique that for me, adds more meaning to what you're saying and certainly captures my attention more than just ordinary statements. Great Job!
Ben H said...
- My favorite thing about this homework is what a good job you did using the insights of Beth and connecting them to your own life. For instance, I thought it was very interesting how you were able to relate something like the time standing still in Erik's situation to your own experience in a soccer game, when normally the two situations would be completely different. I also like when you said, "I like the idea of people having some kind of awareness of their own death and being brave enough to fight it or brave enough to want to accept it and go to it like some new part of the world not yet visited," because it really got me thinking about the way I vew death. Great job!
Saturday, December 11, 2010
HW 22- Illness and Dying Book Part 1
The book that I am reading is titled Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder, published in 2004 by Random House Inc.
Precis- Beginning Section: I was in Haiti 2 weeks before Christmas in 1994, the reason being to report on American soldiers. This is when I first encountered Paul Farmer, a doctor who worked in a hospital a few miles north of Mirebalais. I learned some more about him and ended up sending some donations to his hospital over the next five years, which he responded to with hand written letters of thanks. The next time I saw him was in 1999, in Boston. He was dealing with a patient named Joe who had previously been diagnosed with HIV and other diseases. Farmer wasn't just trying to cure him, though. It seemed like he was really trying to make his life better. In 2000, he invited me to see his oeuvre in Haiti.
"As Farmer was leaving the shelter, he heard Joe say to another resident, just loudly enough to make Farmer wonder if Joe meant for him to overhear, 'That guys a fuckin' saint." (Kidder, 16) This quote inserted a question into my head: how does helping someone to have a better life make them a saint, and what does that say about how considerate are people are of others in general?
"P.J. said: 'But Dad, white people don't pick citrus.'
'Yeah? I'll give you white people." (Kidder, 51) I thought this was interesting because growing up in New York City, what P.J. said is something I never would have said to my father. It also helps us understand why Farmer does not have a problem healing Hatians; because his father knew about them and explained them to him as equals.
"I became aware of the logistical facts of Farmer's life only gradually so they didn't seem completely unusual until I totaled them up." (Kidder, 22) This makes sense to me, because as I was reading in the beginning about Farmer's life, it did seem pretty odd to me why he would have chosen the life that he did.
The most interesting thought that I have had while reading this book so far has had to do with the idea of kindness, and is related to the first quote that is listed. Considering the way that all Paul Farmer did for Joe was his duty as a doctor and a little bit more by trying to make him as comfortable as possible made Joe feel like Farmer was a saint seems to represent that kindness is not something that we experience very often, or not for him. However, the quote goes on to say, "It wasn't the first time Farmer had heard himself called that." (Kidder, 16) It seems like many of those who have been treated by Farmer believe that he is something that he feels he is not only because he did what any doctor should do; cure patients but also treat them like people, and not just test subjects. It feels like many other doctors that Farmer's patients had seen in the book were probably just treating the patients, and not the people, which really just points out that what they're doing is bad and not that what Farmer is doing is saintlike.
Precis- Beginning Section: I was in Haiti 2 weeks before Christmas in 1994, the reason being to report on American soldiers. This is when I first encountered Paul Farmer, a doctor who worked in a hospital a few miles north of Mirebalais. I learned some more about him and ended up sending some donations to his hospital over the next five years, which he responded to with hand written letters of thanks. The next time I saw him was in 1999, in Boston. He was dealing with a patient named Joe who had previously been diagnosed with HIV and other diseases. Farmer wasn't just trying to cure him, though. It seemed like he was really trying to make his life better. In 2000, he invited me to see his oeuvre in Haiti.
"As Farmer was leaving the shelter, he heard Joe say to another resident, just loudly enough to make Farmer wonder if Joe meant for him to overhear, 'That guys a fuckin' saint." (Kidder, 16) This quote inserted a question into my head: how does helping someone to have a better life make them a saint, and what does that say about how considerate are people are of others in general?
"P.J. said: 'But Dad, white people don't pick citrus.'
'Yeah? I'll give you white people." (Kidder, 51) I thought this was interesting because growing up in New York City, what P.J. said is something I never would have said to my father. It also helps us understand why Farmer does not have a problem healing Hatians; because his father knew about them and explained them to him as equals.
"I became aware of the logistical facts of Farmer's life only gradually so they didn't seem completely unusual until I totaled them up." (Kidder, 22) This makes sense to me, because as I was reading in the beginning about Farmer's life, it did seem pretty odd to me why he would have chosen the life that he did.
The most interesting thought that I have had while reading this book so far has had to do with the idea of kindness, and is related to the first quote that is listed. Considering the way that all Paul Farmer did for Joe was his duty as a doctor and a little bit more by trying to make him as comfortable as possible made Joe feel like Farmer was a saint seems to represent that kindness is not something that we experience very often, or not for him. However, the quote goes on to say, "It wasn't the first time Farmer had heard himself called that." (Kidder, 16) It seems like many of those who have been treated by Farmer believe that he is something that he feels he is not only because he did what any doctor should do; cure patients but also treat them like people, and not just test subjects. It feels like many other doctors that Farmer's patients had seen in the book were probably just treating the patients, and not the people, which really just points out that what they're doing is bad and not that what Farmer is doing is saintlike.
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
HW 21- Expert #1
Insights-
1. One thing that I thought was interesting was how neither Beth or Erik ever used the words death or dying in order to provide positive energy.
2. Another experience that Beth shared with us that I thought was interesting was how she chose to take care of him, with only the help of Evan.
3. Finally, one of the more subtle insights in Beth's story was how she said Evan and Josh were very close to their father.
The fact that the words death and dying were never used in the hospital or at any time around Erik is something that I am very familiar with. Every time I have ever visited someone I know in the hospital, words like those were never mentioned. For instance, when my family and I went to visit a good friend of my mother's who had ALS, all we talked about were postive things like how everyone was doing and how the Patriots game went, things like that. Also, the way that Beth took care of her husband with only the help of her 13 year old son is spectacular to me, and also something that I am familiar with. When my grandmother was ill (which was really for as long as I can remember her being alive), my aunt took care of her all by herself for years. They lived on the same property in two different houses, and the only time anyone other than herself would take care of her mother was when she needed to go to work. The third insight about how close Erik was to his to children is actually sort of different from my own life. Although I was always close to my father, he was always out working when I was younger. I imagine that the fact that Evan and Josh were so close to their father was a very good thing, but it also probably made it harder for them when he passed away.
The first question that Beth's presentation sparked for me was something like: How do people's experiences differ when talking about how they were treated by their doctor? The reason this question popped into my head is because Beth said that the oncologist was very cheerful and agreed to treat him with confidence that it would by him some time. However, on many TV shows and even from a lot of family friends that I know, I have heard stories about horrible doctors and bad treatment. In the case of Erik, on the other hand, no medication or treatment was never denied and Beth never even had to pay a hospital bill!
1. One thing that I thought was interesting was how neither Beth or Erik ever used the words death or dying in order to provide positive energy.
2. Another experience that Beth shared with us that I thought was interesting was how she chose to take care of him, with only the help of Evan.
3. Finally, one of the more subtle insights in Beth's story was how she said Evan and Josh were very close to their father.
The fact that the words death and dying were never used in the hospital or at any time around Erik is something that I am very familiar with. Every time I have ever visited someone I know in the hospital, words like those were never mentioned. For instance, when my family and I went to visit a good friend of my mother's who had ALS, all we talked about were postive things like how everyone was doing and how the Patriots game went, things like that. Also, the way that Beth took care of her husband with only the help of her 13 year old son is spectacular to me, and also something that I am familiar with. When my grandmother was ill (which was really for as long as I can remember her being alive), my aunt took care of her all by herself for years. They lived on the same property in two different houses, and the only time anyone other than herself would take care of her mother was when she needed to go to work. The third insight about how close Erik was to his to children is actually sort of different from my own life. Although I was always close to my father, he was always out working when I was younger. I imagine that the fact that Evan and Josh were so close to their father was a very good thing, but it also probably made it harder for them when he passed away.
The first question that Beth's presentation sparked for me was something like: How do people's experiences differ when talking about how they were treated by their doctor? The reason this question popped into my head is because Beth said that the oncologist was very cheerful and agreed to treat him with confidence that it would by him some time. However, on many TV shows and even from a lot of family friends that I know, I have heard stories about horrible doctors and bad treatment. In the case of Erik, on the other hand, no medication or treatment was never denied and Beth never even had to pay a hospital bill!
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
HW 19- Family Perspectives on Illness and Dying
In my family, there is certainly a history of disease. On both my mother and father's sides of the family, everyone is highly prone to skin cancer because of how fair skinned we are and there have been numerous cases on both sides of the family. Another issue in my family has been heart disease, but the only confirmed case of that that I can think of in my family was my grandfather, who used to smoke a lot and did not eat on a particularly healthy diet. Because of these diseases, my family has had a lot of experience visiting friends and family in the hospital, which has led to me visiting the hospital quite a bit as well. The experiences that my parents have had dealing with illness and dying are the kind of things that make me afraid of growing older.
My father is the youngest of a family of six siblings; he is even nine minutes younger than his twin sister. His father died when he was only two years old and was raised by just his mom for his whole childhood. His mother (my grandmother) was in an accident not to long after I was born where she hit her head so hard that she began to internally bleed into her brain. For as long as I can remember, although she was able to think just as quickly as she had before, something happened where she could not get the words out, and the only word I ever remember her saying was "yes." She was ill for her entire life, but every time I saw my father around her he would always act and look perfectly happy, just like the rest of my family. I was young, so I unfortunately did not do as good of a job looking happy and I really just felt awkward around her... which I came to regret deeply when she finally passed away.
My mother has also had her fair share of dealing with illness and dying. Her father had two heart attacks in his lifetime, and did not survive long after the second one. However, unlike my fathers family, everyone on my mothers side lives out of range for us to visit often; in California. So my mother did not have to pretend like she was not worried. However, back when my godfather was in a car accident that nearly killed him, she immediately left to go see him. Not that this is an unreasonable norm for dealing with the ill and dying, but the response of my family to someone who is sick has been to immediately go out and visit them in the hospital, even if they are 2000 miles away like my godfather was. Another good friend of my mothers was diagnosed with ALS recently, which completely took away his ability to move and speak. I remember visiting him with my family a few times, and watching as she was as supporting and kind beside the hospital bed as I have ever seen her.
My father is the youngest of a family of six siblings; he is even nine minutes younger than his twin sister. His father died when he was only two years old and was raised by just his mom for his whole childhood. His mother (my grandmother) was in an accident not to long after I was born where she hit her head so hard that she began to internally bleed into her brain. For as long as I can remember, although she was able to think just as quickly as she had before, something happened where she could not get the words out, and the only word I ever remember her saying was "yes." She was ill for her entire life, but every time I saw my father around her he would always act and look perfectly happy, just like the rest of my family. I was young, so I unfortunately did not do as good of a job looking happy and I really just felt awkward around her... which I came to regret deeply when she finally passed away.
My mother has also had her fair share of dealing with illness and dying. Her father had two heart attacks in his lifetime, and did not survive long after the second one. However, unlike my fathers family, everyone on my mothers side lives out of range for us to visit often; in California. So my mother did not have to pretend like she was not worried. However, back when my godfather was in a car accident that nearly killed him, she immediately left to go see him. Not that this is an unreasonable norm for dealing with the ill and dying, but the response of my family to someone who is sick has been to immediately go out and visit them in the hospital, even if they are 2000 miles away like my godfather was. Another good friend of my mothers was diagnosed with ALS recently, which completely took away his ability to move and speak. I remember visiting him with my family a few times, and watching as she was as supporting and kind beside the hospital bed as I have ever seen her.
Sunday, November 28, 2010
HW 18- Health & Illness & Feasting
My experience of Thanksgiving this year was similar to the way I experience it practically every year, and practically every year Thanksgiving is one of the few times of the year that completely fits in to the aspects of our countries practices that relate to physicality. I know for a fact that there are many people that just use Thanksgiving as an excuse to eat as much food as they want and that there are also many that couldn't even explain what the holiday is meant to celebrate. In my family, it feels like Thanksgiving is becoming less and less traditional and cultural and more just about the physicality of eating as much food as we want. For instance, almost every year for this holiday, my parents and I gather with the rest of my family at my aunt and uncle's house. However, this year my parents wanted to go down the block instead to a party where not even they knew many of the people that would be there. There certainly was going to be a lot of food there, however.
Another tradition that my parents and I missed out on with my family was sitting around the TV with everyone and watching football. Although it does not sound like a necessarily thankful thing to do, it has become practically a cultural ceremony in many families across the country, and I'm sure there are many that would argue that it is a good thing to do because football is a very "American" game. These two activities of eating as much food as you can and lying around and watching TV afterwards are not exactly "healthy" things to do, and further represent how the holiday of Thanksgiving is one of the few times where body-centered practices dominate over anti-body practices.
In my opinion, it is not necessarily a bad thing that there is one day every year that is almost completely devoted to body-centered practices, because all the others are practically all connected with the mind. In fact, another way that Thanksgiving reminds us of our physicality is the way many people tend to feel the next day. After such rapid consumption of food that, very often, is not necessarily healthy for you, many people will feel very tired initially after the meal. After a little while, some people will probably experience stomach pain while others might continue to experience fatigue. This idea is similar to what we talked about in class, and how only when a person is ill is when they truly start to consider their physicality. This is yet another reason that represents how Thanksgiving is becoming completely based on body-centered practices over anti-body practices, especially in families like mine.
Another tradition that my parents and I missed out on with my family was sitting around the TV with everyone and watching football. Although it does not sound like a necessarily thankful thing to do, it has become practically a cultural ceremony in many families across the country, and I'm sure there are many that would argue that it is a good thing to do because football is a very "American" game. These two activities of eating as much food as you can and lying around and watching TV afterwards are not exactly "healthy" things to do, and further represent how the holiday of Thanksgiving is one of the few times where body-centered practices dominate over anti-body practices.
In my opinion, it is not necessarily a bad thing that there is one day every year that is almost completely devoted to body-centered practices, because all the others are practically all connected with the mind. In fact, another way that Thanksgiving reminds us of our physicality is the way many people tend to feel the next day. After such rapid consumption of food that, very often, is not necessarily healthy for you, many people will feel very tired initially after the meal. After a little while, some people will probably experience stomach pain while others might continue to experience fatigue. This idea is similar to what we talked about in class, and how only when a person is ill is when they truly start to consider their physicality. This is yet another reason that represents how Thanksgiving is becoming completely based on body-centered practices over anti-body practices, especially in families like mine.
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
HW 17
Fortunately, my experiences with illness and dying have not been too extensive. I have visited multiple family members and a close friend of family a few times at the hospital, but have not myself had to deal with severe illness. (even though some would say that we are dying the moment we are born, I prefer not to look at life in such a negative way) In a way, I have been taught to see illness and dying as something that is just a part of life, and every now and then I find myself thinking about it and becoming a little depressed. After all, it is a depressing thought, knowing that everyone including yourself will have to deal with illness in their lives.
I have also always had a dislike for hospitals in general, because in my life all the times that I have had to visit the hospital it has been for a bad occasion, and never for something like giving birth. This has placed an unfair bias in my mind that hospitals are miserable places, and all the hospital shows on television today as well as the people I know who have spent a long time in the hospital also do a good job of emphasizing how the patients really just want to be free. My family has been around much longer than I have, and have had a lot more time to think about these issues. They have learned to accept the fact that practically everyone will deal with illness and dying, and have had a lot more experience in the past with both of those things than I have.
To be honest, I am not really familiar with the social norms involved with illness and dying. However, I am aware that it has become very common for parents to get a lot of vaccines for their children when they are very young, and it is "normal" for many people to go to the doctors office for an annual check-up. Something I don't usually think about much is how much humans pay attention to their health compared to other animals; we brush our teeth, we constantly go to doctors and specialists, we always wash our hands... and other creatures just eat what they can to survive. It seems like humans pay so much attention to avoiding illness that we end up living unnaturally long lives.
I have also always had a dislike for hospitals in general, because in my life all the times that I have had to visit the hospital it has been for a bad occasion, and never for something like giving birth. This has placed an unfair bias in my mind that hospitals are miserable places, and all the hospital shows on television today as well as the people I know who have spent a long time in the hospital also do a good job of emphasizing how the patients really just want to be free. My family has been around much longer than I have, and have had a lot more time to think about these issues. They have learned to accept the fact that practically everyone will deal with illness and dying, and have had a lot more experience in the past with both of those things than I have.
To be honest, I am not really familiar with the social norms involved with illness and dying. However, I am aware that it has become very common for parents to get a lot of vaccines for their children when they are very young, and it is "normal" for many people to go to the doctors office for an annual check-up. Something I don't usually think about much is how much humans pay attention to their health compared to other animals; we brush our teeth, we constantly go to doctors and specialists, we always wash our hands... and other creatures just eat what they can to survive. It seems like humans pay so much attention to avoiding illness that we end up living unnaturally long lives.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)